Essay: Pier A should be a farmer’s market like New Amsterdam

This post has been read 3436 times!

Essay, Opinion February 2, 2013 By Steven E. Greer, MD

After decades of throwing cash into the money pit called Pier A in the southernmost tip of Manhattan, the City of New York managed to unload this headache onto the Battery Park City Authority in 2008. The BPCA, then headed by Chairman James Gill and CEO James Cavanaugh, agreed to take on the task of renovating the outer shell of Pier A, ostensibly because local residents were complaining about the appearance.

The BPCA, an agency jointly controlled by the city and state, and was also doing a favor to then Governor Spitzer and Mayor Bloomberg by assuming control of Pier A. By removing the costs of Pier A from the state and city budgets, those deficits were thereby reduced. However, it was merely a shell game.

To the BPCA’s credit, under the leadership of Gill and Cavanaugh, they were much more effective than the city ever was at getting Pier A close to being ready for public use. However, under the guidance of BPCA Chairman Bill Thompson and his CEO Gayle Horwitz, Pier A fell behind schedule and over budget once again. Exacerbating the challenges to the project, Gayle Horwitz culled the ranks by firing 19 BPCA staffers with institutional wisdom about construction projects in Battery Park City. (The BPCA is now planning to take the savings from those headcount reductions and parley them into raises for the remaining staff, similar to the recent 45% increase in pay for BPCA employee Anne Fenton)

The deal with the city, back in 2008, was for the BPCA to accept $30 Million in funds from the city’s NYCEDC for the development of the exterior building shell of Pier A, while the Pier remained property of the city. The BPCA was the official agency that awarded Pier A to the Poulakakos family to build a restaurant, with approval from the NYCEDC. An Italian heritage group also submitted an RFP application, but the Poulakakos group won, according to a source closely involved with the process.

The BPCA seemed to bypass the usual level of public discussion about Pier A and the RFP during BPCA meetings. Many in the community, such as CB 1 Treasurer John Fratta, felt that the whole process was intentionally secretive and opaque, and that the decision was a “slap in the face” to the Italian Community who wanted a museum to compliment the nearby Jewish and Irish museums.

Now, the Pier A project has exceeded the capped $30 Million allocated by the NYCEDC and has become a financial liability to the BPCA. At the most recent BPCA board meeting, Donald Capoccia said, “We should never be in this position again.”, meaning that the BPCA should never agree to be on the hook for cost overruns of a project managed by a third party, with that third party reaping the benefits of the revenue upside and having no downside risk to cost overruns. A source close to the BPCA believes that the BPCA does have the right to refuse to continue development past the $30 Million budget cap and return the project to the city. BatteryPark.TV does not yet have the actual contract to view.

The plans of the Poulakakos family to develop Pier A are now also becoming unpopular with the community. They intend to turn Pier A into essentially a “booze cruise” destination for party boats that will likely also bring in tour buses to the quiet residential streets. Tour buses are already a top concern for the district.

The ongoing Poulakakos restaurant expansion, from their origins at Harry’s Steak in the Financial District in the 1980’s into Battery Park City, seems overly ambitious. The son of the family, Peter Poulakakos, is the main visionary and day-to-day head of operations, and his track record is unproven. Their expansion onto Stone Street in the 2000’s included mostly drinking pubs with bar food, and a chain of coffee shops. Now, they have been awarded not only the large Pier A, but also the nearby Battery Maritime Building. In addition, as first reported by BatteryPark.TV, the Brookfield company is reportedly close to allowing them to build a 25,000 square foot food court in the renovated World Financial Center, with the goal of emulating the Eataly or Chelsea Market  locations in Midtown.

So far, the Maritime Building restaurant and the Pier A restaurant are years behind schedule, and their Stone Street portfolio of Poulakakos restaurants was dealt a major setback after Hurricane Sandy. The Poulakakos family might be overextended and underqualified to expand into Battery Park City with two new large projects.

Pier A is now a money-losing liability for Battery Park City and the BPCA. It is time to seriously reconsider the fate of Pier A and what is best for the residential setting of Battery Park.

If the Poulakakos family wants to bite off the WFC food court project, then they should be required to return Pier A to the BPCA for another developer to complete. Not only are they possibly spread too thin, and unproven, but their monopoly over BPC would have a chilling effect on any local leader who might want to oppose them.

The BPCA should also consider handing control of Pier A back to the city. City Counsel Speaker Christine Quinn spoke to a group of Wall Street executives and mentioned that New York should diversify away from the reliance on the financial sector, and into technology industries and food industries. Pier A would make for an ideal artisan food market, similar to the New Amsterdam Market in the Seaport. With substandard grocery stories nearby, the demand for a market would be tremendous.

Related stories:

Pier A plans are “A slap in the face to Italian Americans”

Clever bookkeeping by BPCA understates cost overruns of Pier A

Pier A is shaping up to be an extension of the touristy Liberty Tours scene, with booze

Poulakakos run food market coming to WFC

This entry was posted in - Op-Ed, Real estate, State Government, Videos. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Essay: Pier A should be a farmer’s market like New Amsterdam

  1. Marya says:

    Well done! Let’s make it happen!

  2. Barbara says:

    I agree I feel Pier A complex is not serving the Battery Park City Community, it is more is a tourist destination for the City within Battery Park.

  3. Una Perkins says:

    I have read about one of the suggestions regarding Pier A; is a Farmer’s Market. While I respect the comments made by John Fratta of Community Bd’s .1 suggestion.
    As an Afro-America-Native American heritage, I feel if that there should definitely be a Black History Museum, especially in Lower Manhattan. When Blacks came to the shores of Lower Manhattan, they came as slaves & indenture servants. Unlike the Europeans. Blacks were not given a choice. They attended the farms, built Wall Street, the sewers, the water fronts etc. In-spite of the enslavement, and set back,”they”, carried on and when Emancipated, “they” never received reparation as did the Italians for their labor. Blacks went on to have their own business, like book Bindery, and other business, and contributed so much more, too numerous to list. I recommend reading, Slavery In New York. I too am on Community Bd#1, and I am a Historian, but not professional.
    Thanks for allowing me to comment.
    Una L Perkins

  4. This post is dead-on. Well said. Good argument.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *